What Was the Misunderstanding Regarding the Apostle John's Death?
The misunderstanding arose at the close of John's Gospel, after the risen Lord restored Peter and spoke of the death by which Peter would glorify God. Peter then asked about John, and Jesus answered conditionally, tying John's remaining to His own will and His own coming (John 21:22). The brethren took that conditional answer as a promise and passed along the saying that John would not die. The inspired narrator corrects it plainly: Jesus did not say John would not die, but spoke only of His will and His coming (John 21:23). So the error was not in the words themselves but in how they were handled — a hypothetical was turned into a declaration. The Lord's purpose was to turn Peter away from comparing his lot with another servant's and back to his own calling to follow. Scripture does not record John's death, nor does it tell us how long he lived, so we should not build doctrine on silence. What is settled is that Jesus gave no guarantee that John would escape death; the misunderstanding was a rumor that outgrew the sentence spoken.
The setting matters. Jesus had just spoken to Peter about the death by which he would glorify God (John 21:19), and Peter's question about John grew out of that sober announcement. The Lord's answer joined a sovereign condition to His own coming, and among disciples who lived in expectation of His return such a saying was easy to repeat and easy to overstate. John himself, the disciple whom Jesus loved, is the one whose Gospel records both the saying and its correction, and John 21:24 identifies him as the witness who wrote these things. Notice what the correction does and does not do. It denies that Jesus promised John would not die. It does not say John died; it does not say he lived until the Lord's return. Later readers have sometimes drawn conclusions from tradition or from the Lord's words about John tarrying, but the text leaves the manner and timing of John's death unstated. The safe lesson is to let a conditional word remain conditional, and to attend to one's own calling rather than to speculate about another's.
This spake he, signifying by what death he should glorify God. And when he had spoken this, he saith unto him, Follow me.
John 21:22Jesus saith unto him, If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that to thee? follow thou me.
John 21:23Then went this saying abroad among the brethren, that that disciple should not die: yet Jesus said not unto him, He shall not die; but, If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that to thee?
John 21:24This is the disciple which testifieth of these things, and wrote these things: and we know that his testimony is true.
How many of John's eight signs happened before Jesus' death, burial, and resurrection?
Seven of the eight signs recorded in John's Gospel took place before Jesus' death, burial, and resurrection. The remaining eighth sign is found in the final chapter of John and is described as a sign of new beginnings. Thus seven preceded the completed work, while the eighth followed.
How many of John's signs happened before Jesus' death, burial, and resurrection?
Seven of John’s eight recorded signs occurred before Jesus’ death, burial, and resurrection. The Gospel of John contains eight signs, all miracles, and the first seven preceded the completion of that work. The eighth sign appears in John’s last chapter and is called the sign of new beginnings.