Les Feldick Bible Study

Did the Disciples Preach the Crucifixion Initially?

Initially, during Jesus' earthly ministry, the disciples did not preach His crucifixion as the center of their message. They were sent to Israel with the announcement that the kingdom was at hand and that Jesus was the Messiah. Jesus did foretell His suffering and death, but the disciples did not understand it; Luke records that the meaning was concealed from them, and they were afraid to ask Him about it (Luke 18:34). Their silence was not mainly rebellion but unfinished revelation and unopened understanding. The crucifixion had not yet taken place, and its meaning as the sin-bearing work of Christ was not yet fully disclosed to them. Only after His resurrection did Jesus open their understanding, and afterward they became witnesses of His death and resurrection. So the reason the disciples did not preach about Christ's crucifixion initially is that they did not yet comprehend it, it was not yet accomplished, and their first commission was the gospel of the kingdom to Israel. In the early chapters of Acts, once the Spirit had come and they understood, they did preach the crucified Christ (Acts 2:23).

The question needs care, because the cross was never an afterthought in God's purpose. It was foretold, and Jesus spoke of it plainly. Yet the Twelve's early preaching centered on the nearness of the kingdom and the identity of Jesus as Messiah, not on His death as a finished work. Even when He told them, they did not grasp it; Mark records that they failed to grasp His words and were afraid to question Him (Mark 9:32). After the resurrection, their message changed because the facts had been accomplished and their understanding was opened. In Acts, Peter declares that Jesus was handed over according to God's settled plan and foreknowledge, and that wicked men crucified Him (Acts 2:23). Later he says that God fulfilled what the prophets had spoken concerning the Messiah's suffering (Acts 3:18). Dispensationally, we should not read the later revelation of the mystery given through Paul back into the Gospels. The Twelve's initial ministry was to Israel in the prophetic program; the cross became central to their witness after the resurrection. Scripture does not explain every reason for their earlier silence, so we should state what is written and leave the rest with God.

What gospel did Jesus and His disciples preach before the accomplishment?

Before the accomplishment, Jesus and His disciples preached the gospel of the kingdom—the good news that the King is coming, the King is here, and the King was ready to set up His kingdom as offered to Israel. He and the Twelve preached it for almost three years.

Why couldn't the disciples preach a gospel based on the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus?

They could not preach such a gospel because the events had not yet occurred: He had not died, He had not been raised from the dead, and the message was still confined to Israel. The disciples did not yet understand, so a gospel based on death, burial, and resurrection could not be proclaimed.