What Was Abraham's Concern Regarding Ishmael?
Abraham's concern regarding Ishmael was that his son by Hagar might be excluded from God's favor and future blessing. In Genesis 17:18, after God promised that Sarah would bear a son, Abraham interceded for Ishmael, asking that he might live before the Lord. The plea likely includes both preservation and spiritual acceptance: Abraham did not want Ishmael merely to exist, but to stand in God's presence and share in the blessings of Abraham's house. God answered in Genesis 17:20 by promising that Ishmael would be blessed, fruitful, and multiplied, and that he would become a great nation. Yet God also made clear that the covenant would be established with Isaac, not Ishmael. Later, when Hagar and Ishmael were sent away, Abraham was deeply grieved because of his son (Genesis 21:11). God again reassured him that Ishmael would become a nation because he was Abraham's seed. So Abraham's concern was a father's loving intercession: he wanted Ishmael to live before God and not be cast off. Scripture shows God heard that concern, granting Ishmael real but distinct blessings, while reserving the covenant line for Isaac. The exact nuance of Abraham's plea is not fully explained in the text, but the overall picture is clear.
The extended context in Genesis 17:19 helps clarify God's answer: the covenant promise passes to Isaac, and Ishmael's blessing, though genuine, is not the covenant line. Abraham's concern should not be read as opposition to God's promise. The narrative places his plea immediately after the announcement of Isaac, suggesting he was seeking assurance for the son he already had. God did not rebuke Abraham for asking; He answered with promises of fruitfulness and national greatness for Ishmael. Later, in Genesis 21:11, Abraham's grief over sending Ishmael away shows his continuing fatherly love. God's response in that later crisis repeats the pattern: Ishmael will be preserved and made a nation, but the promised line will continue through Isaac. Scripture does not tell us every detail of Abraham's inner thoughts, so we should not overstate them. What is clear is that Abraham cared for Ishmael's life and standing before God, and God answered with both mercy and covenant clarity.
And Abraham said unto God, O that Ishmael might live before thee!
Genesis 17:19And God said, Sarah thy wife shall bear thee a son indeed; and thou shalt call his name Isaac: and I will establish my covenant with him for an everlasting covenant, and with his seed after him.
Genesis 17:20And as for Ishmael, I have heard thee: Behold, I have blessed him, and will make him fruitful, and will multiply him exceedingly; twelve princes shall he beget, and I will make him a great nation.
Genesis 21:11And the thing was very grievous in Abraham’s sight because of his son.
Did God's covenant with Abraham continue through Ishmael or Isaac?
God's covenant with Abraham continued through Isaac, not Ishmael. The promise and covenants were explicitly carried forward through the promised son, Isaac, rather than through Ishmael. Scripture thus identifies Isaac as the heir of the Abrahamic promise, confirming that God's covenant line ran through him.
How did God answer Abraham's request that Ishmael be the heir?
God refuted Abraham’s request and declined to make Ishmael the heir. He told Abraham that Sarah, his wife—not the slave girl—would bear him a son to be named Isaac, and God would establish His everlasting covenant with Isaac, not Ishmael.